General/Finance Committee

Sustainable Funding for Hospice Muskoka

Donna Kearney, Executive Director of Hospice Muskoka, was before Committee asking for Township support for permanent and stable funding from the Province of Ontario. Ms. Kearney explained that the Province funds three of the ten beds at Andy’s House in Port Carling, funds half the cost of staffing and one quarter of their operating expenses. Andy’s House is staffed by two nurse practitioners, of which Ms. Kearney is one. The Province provided funding for one nurse practitioner the first year Andy’s House was open, but that funding was not renewed. Hospice Muskoka has been able to “rent” five beds in Andy’s House to Muskoka Algonquin Healthcare, so their extra beds do not sit empty. Hospice Muskoka has had 100% occupancy in the last six months. These beds are not only used by residents of Muskoka, but individuals have also been travelling from Orillia, Barrie and Toronto as hospice beds are simply not available elsewhere.
Hospice Muskoka has served over 300 individuals in the three years since Andy’s House opened.

Ms. Kearney explained that although the number of donations received by Hospice Muskoka this past year has increased, the value of the donations has decreased by $300,000.00. Ms. Kearney further explained that if the funding agreement with the Province that expires in March 2024 is not renewed, Hospice Muskoka risks closing.

Councillor Edwards asked what the savings were to the MAHC when renting beds at Hospice Muskoka. Ms. Kearney replied that hospice beds are one third the cost of hospital beds. Councillor Edwards then encouraged his fellow Councillors to take a tour of Andy’s House.

A resolution was read to forward this item directly to the Council meeting in the afternoon. See more under Council.

Wednesday, November 15th, 2023

Arena Feasibility Study

Susan Lennox from Lennox Architects Ltd presented the second phase of the arena feasibility study to Committee. Ms. Lennox explained that following her first presentation an online survey was uploaded on the Township’s website and twelve user groups were interviewed either in person or on the phone. Ms. Lennox reviewed the Community Needs Assessment results with Committee, which can be found here – Click Here . Following the presentation Corey Moore, Manager of Parks, Recreation and Facilities informed Committee that the results indicated that those who took part in the survey showed a strong interest in having an indoor swimming pool in the Township.

Councillor Moyer Kent voiced a concern that the survey results were skewed as those interested in increased pickleball courts are very active in obtaining them. Councillor Moyer Kent felt that the core group was underrepresented. Ms. Lennox replied that pickleball was well represented with 48% of responses. Furthermore, several groups such as hockey were represented by their organizer and not each individual. Ms. Lennox explained that they had been asked to review the arenas and asked Committee what other amenities they wish to consider in the arenas. CAO Hammond added that Ms. Lennox was looking for direction on what might fit on the arena sites, and that no decision was being made that day to include anything extra.

A resolution was read to include the possibility of a swimming pool in a new arena. The resolution carried.

Capital Works Level of Service Analysis

Director of Public Works, Ken Becking, informed Committee that the Township has created an asset management plan regarding core infrastructure, but that plan does not include future needs. Mr. Becking asked Committee to approve the Terms of Reference for a Capital Works Level of Service Analysis – Click Here – to review what services the Township provides, what services they should provide and to what extent these services should be provided.

Councillor Moyer Kent voiced concerns with the timelines of this request and suggested that the review take place during the first quarter of 2024 so it could be included in 2025 budget discussions. Mr. Becking explained that the Township is undertaking a new Strategic Plan, and the service level study will be informed by the Strategic Plan. CAO Hammond reminded Committee that the Township is also currently undertaking an arena feasibility study and a fire station location study. Information from these studies will help the Township decide on “the what” and then Council will decide on “the how”. Councillor Nishikawa explained that she did not feel this should be rushed.

A resolution was read to endorse the Terms of Reference and carried.

2020-2024 Strategic Plan

CAO Hammond explained to Committee that a Strategic Plan is a guide to direct Council and staff. The last strategic plan was written to bridge the terms of Council, but it is time for this Council to review their visions. CAO Hammond asked Committee members to endorse the Terms of Reference and that staff be authorized to prepare and issue a Request for Proposal. CAO Hammond further stated that once the budget process has been completed, he hoped to start the review of the Strategic Plan and have it completed in six months.

The resolution was read and carried with no discussion.

Council

January Meeting Schedule

Township meeting week is usually the full second week of the month, but with the Township Offices being closed for the holiday season staff requested that meeting week be held the third week of January 2024. As this week corresponds with District meetings the dates of the Township meeting days have been changed. A resolution was read and carried to reschedule Township meetings to:

  • Committee of Adjustment – Monday, January 15th, 2024, at 9 AM
  • General/Finance Committee – Tuesday, January 16th, 2024, at 9 AM
  • Council – Tuesday, January 16th, 2024, at 1 PM
  • Planning Committee – Friday, January 19th, 2024, at 9 AM

Wednesday, November 15th, 2023

Hospice Muskoka

Following the presentation in the morning by Donna Kearney, Executive Director of Hospice Muskoka, Council heard a resolution directing the Mayor to write to Premier Ford and the Minister of Health to urge the Province for sustainable funding for Hospice Muskoka on a priority basis. Further, that the resolution and letter be forwarded to MPP Graydon Smith, Chiefs of Watha and Moose Deer Point and all other local municipalities for their support. The resolution carried.

ED Note: The Muskoka Ratepayers were pleased to see Councillors show such support for Hospice Muskoka.

Planning Committee

Comprehensive Zoning By-Law Update

Manager of Planning, Bryce Sharpe, explained to Committee that the Township’s Official Plan was being considered by the District and once approved the Township will be required to review the Comprehensive Zoning By-Law (CZBL) within three years. Mr. Sharpe presented to Committee a Community Planning Permit System (CPPS)  – Click Here – which could be put in place of the CZBL stating that the CPPS would streamline planning applications and only applicants would be able to appeal decisions. The CPPS is different from the CZBL as it can include conditions of approval such as tree removal and provides more flexibility regarding what can be delegated to staff. The CPPS would allow applications to be broken down into three separate classes: Class I staff approval, Class II staff approval or elevate it to Committee or Council approval and Class III Committee or Council approval. The CPPS is being suggested now as planning application fees must be refunded if timelines are not being met. As well, Bill 23 allows for the use of site plan control on single residential properties and the CPPS allows for input into exterior design of structures.

Discussions began with Council Zavitz questioning if the Planning Department has the time and resources to effect such a change? Director of Development Services & Environmental Sustainability, David Pink, replied that changing from the CZBL to CPPS will be a “very large project” but staff will be able to accommodate the change. Mayor Kelley stated that he did not have enough information to make a decision and questioned what problems they were trying to fix by making this change. Councillors Moyer Kent and Burry were in agreement with Mayor Kelley. Councillor Mazan stated that she felt the presentation was a great introduction to the CPPS, but she required more time to make a decision. Councillor Bosomworth felt that pros and cons for each by-law could be supplied to Committee, as he felt a “con” to the CPPS would be that the community may not have as much right to be involved in applications as they do now and suggested that input should be received from the public. CAO Hammond felt that the discussion could be deferred to December and staff would return with a report on information they received from the key stakeholder groups.

A resolution was read and carried to return to the December 2023 with Terms of Reference to update the Township’s Comprehensive Zoning By-Law.

Thursday, November 16th, 2023

Approaches to Address Feeding Wildlife

As reported in the July Township Watch – Township Watch – July 2023 – a private individual approached the Township regarding implementing a wildlife feeding by-law within the limits of Port Carling. Chief Municipal By-Law Enforcement Officer, Rob Kennedy returned to Committee with recommendations on how to proceed with the request. Mr. Kennedy informed Committee that no other municipality in the District of Muskoka has a wildlife feeding by-law, although Bracebridge has just completed public consultation on one. Staff recommended to committee that no action be taken, except perhaps posting information on the negative impacts of feeding wildlife on the Township website.

Councillor Roberts referenced sites on the best ways to care and feed animals and suggested that they be linked on the web site. Councillor Bosomworth asked if by-law enforcement officers have the ability to speak to individuals who are feeding the wildlife and ask that they stop. Mr. Kennedy felt that this request was not a good use of staff time without policy in place.

A resolution was read that an educational approach will be taken regarding feeding wildlife. The resolution carried.

Short-Term Rental Regulations Pathway

Councillor Roberts asked that this item be added to the agenda for two reasons. Firstly, last month when Committee voted to proceed to a public meeting on the Short-Term Rental Licensing By-Law no date was confirmed, Councillor Roberts suggested it be held in the first two weeks of February 2024. Councillor Zavitz questioned why this was being discussed as no questions were asked regarding this by-law when it was ratified at Council the day before. Director of Development Services & Environmental Sustainability, David Pink, explained that a mailing would have to be done following the holidays and he felt that the community should be allowed at least a month to form their views and opinions. Staff were hoping to hold the meeting in late February or March, but Mr. Pink stated that if Committee wished to pick a date, he would accommodate them.

Secondly, Councillor Roberts felt a line needs to be “drawn in the sand” as following discussions last month, staff stated that the completion of the by-law would not be until 2025. Councillor Roberts stated that those who are reaching out to him are shocked that the by-law will not be in place for the 2024 summer season. Councillor Roberts said it would be beneficial to Committee and the public if staff could provide them with details on the next steps and a breakdown of the “deliverables”. In reply, CAO Hammond stated that the request was premature and that he had concerns with staff spending time and resources on a by-law that has not been passed. Mr. Pink explained that staff anticipate many comments from the community and staff will then have to digest the comments before returning to Committee with them, Committee will then debate the comments and he did not see a by-law being considered until at least early summer 2024 and it won’t be until 2025 that the by-law is “up and running”. Councillor Zavitz pointed out that this by-law is not a foregone conclusion, and he anticipates people will offer their opinions on it.

ED Note: Councillor Roberts said that he has not heard from anyone who is not in favour of the proposed short-term rental licensing by-law, and stated those against were welcome to call him and discuss it.

District Council

Township of Muskoka Lakes Official Plan

As reported in the October Township Watch – Township Watch – October 2023 – Township Council endorsed a modified Official Plan (OP) at the October 2023 Council meeting. The OP was then forwarded to the District of Muskoka for their approval, as they are the approval authority. The modified Township’s OP was presented to District Council this month. As had occurred at the Township Council table an extensive and in-depth discussion on aggregate policies occurred. After much discussion District Council voted against District staff’s recommendations and agreed to include the Township’s modified wording regarding aggregate uses in the Township of Muskoka Lakes. Concerns regarding wording in lake plans included in the OP were then discussed.

A resolution to approve the adopted and amended OP as modified by District staff was defeated. A second resolution to approve the OP as adopted by the Township of Muskoka Lakes regarding aggregate uses and including other modifications recommended by District staff was carried unanimously.

ED Note: The Muskoka Ratepayers congratulates the past and current Councils, Township staff and District staff on all their hard work and dedication on the Official Plan.

Monday, November 20th, 2023

Just a friendly reminder that if you
drop ash off at the
Friends of Muskoka Watershed ash drive,
please make sure ashes are COLD!