Late Breaking News

The Board of the MRA would like to congratulate Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink, on his appointment to Chief Administrative Officer for the Township of Muskoka Lakes.  Mr. Pink will replace CAO Derrick Hammond when he retires in July 2024.   The Township’s press release can be read here.

General/Finance Committee

New Director of Operational Services

The General/Finance Committee began with Chair Mazan welcoming Nick Colucci, the Township’s new Director of Operational Services. Mr. Colucci comes to the Township with 15 years of municipal leadership experience, as well as a “rich background in the private sector”.

ED Note: The MRA also welcomes Mr. Colucci to his position at the Township.

Wednesday, May 15th, 2024

Walking Trails on Crown Lands within the Township

Ken Reese presented the proposal of walking trails adjacent to Skeleton Lake and Bent River on behalf of Ed Olsen. Mr. Reese explained that Mr. Olsen is a fourth generation pioneer family that settled in the Ullswater area in the 1870’s. Mr. Olsen had the idea of these walking trails and Mr. Reese put Mr. Olsen’s thoughts on paper. They are proposing four trails ranging from 6 km to 9 km in open back country located on crown lands.

Councillors Nishikawa, Edwards and Burry all felt that prior to considering this request that a staff report should be done to see if the Province would be interested in using the lands for trails and that hunting in the area be researched as well for safety reasons. Manager of Parks, Recreation and Facilities, Corey Moore, said he would be happy to analyze the proposal and return with a staff report. Mayor Kelley voiced concerns that the proposed trails cross private property, parking lots will be required for hiker’s cars and that the start and end of each of these trails are not near each other. Councillor Nishikawa felt that this was a good opportunity for the Township to reinstate the Muskoka Lakes Trails Committee as all trails in the Township were built by the community.

A resolution was read and carried for staff to return with a staff report.

Communications Strategy

Crystal Paroschy, Director of Legislative Services, presented the communications strategy for the Communications Advisor who was away. Ms. Paroschy explained that this is the first draft of the communication strategy – Click Here – which had been developed “in house” from interviews with Council, staff and stakeholders, as well as a survey on Engage Muskoka Lakes and discussion with comparator municipalities. Staff are recommending the following eight goals and objectives:

  • Strong internal communications
  • Improve online presence
  • Develop a consistent approach to engagement
  • Formalize brand identity
  • Execute planned, proactive communications
  • Embrace partnerships
  • Utilize plain language
  • Encourage in-person interactions

Councillor Zavitz commented that he saw Facebook and Twitter mentioned in the report and asked why the Township would not utilize Instagram too. Ms. Paroschy explained that Instagram is “picture focused” and municipalities tend to stay away from it. Councillor McIntyre stated that one of her pet peeves was using plain language in reports and avoiding the use of acronyms and that she felt that Township reports were geared to those with university educations. Councillor McIntyre suggested that perhaps a plain language summary could be attached to the longer reports so all could read and understand. Councillor Nishikawa pointed out that a large portion of the population is being omitted by not using public notice boards in post offices to communicate with the public. It was further suggested that banks and stores could also be used to help “get the word out” for the Township, as well as the Township of Muskoka Lakes Library and information boards at the Community Centres. Ms. Paroschy explained that the Township has an email list of “associations” who receive emails, and that she would look into using Hall Boards.

A resolution for Councillors to provide feedback on the communications strategy to staff before May 30th, 2024 was read and carried.

Fire Station Location Study Phase II

Fire Chief Murrell presented Phase II of the Fire Station Location Study to Committee. Chief Murrell explained that a Fire Master Plan was completed in June 2022 and last year the Fire Station Location Study began with Phase I being received in December 2023. The report in the agenda package offered three options for the fire stations:

  • One ~ status quo
  • Two ~ reduce the number of stations by three which involves merging the following stations: Glen Orchard with Foote’s Bay, Walker’s Point with Torrance and Raymond with Windermere
  • Three ~ reduce the total number of stations to five

With the current state of the fire stations in the Township Option One is not recommended, leaving two options.

Councillor Nishikawa explained that the train tracks in Torrance raise a big concern for residents in Ward A regarding how the fire department will access their properties. Chief Murrell said that was taken into consideration with the Risk Assessments and Fire Master Plan and explained that the Township does have stations on both sides of the train tracks to respond to calls.

A resolution was read to receive Phase II of the Fire Station Study and to obtain further stakeholder feedback to update the final draft of the study. The resolution carried.

Council

Request for Proposal for By-Law Update

Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink, explained to Council that when a Municipality updates their Official Plan, they must then complete a review of the Comprehensive Zoning By-Law. Three bids were received to complete the work and staff were recommending that the contract be awared to Meridian Planning Consultants and The Planning Partnership who submitted a joint proposal.

Council voted to appoint Meridian Planning Consultants and The Planning Partnership.

Wednesday, May 15th, 2024

Walker’s Point Community Centre Kitchen Upgrade

Following the March 2024 Council meeting – Township Watch – March 2024 – staff re-tendered the Walker’s Point Community Centre kitchen ventilation system upgrades. Two bids were received for the work and staff recommended that the contract be awarded to MAK Mechanical Ltd. Councillors Nishikawa and McIntyre asked for confirmation that the stove that will be installed is electric and that it had been ordered. Corey Moore, Manager of Parks, Recreation and Facilities, replied in the affirmative to both questions.

Council voted to award the contract.

Special Events Permit

At the beginning of the Council meeting, Council heard delegations on the Special Events Permit By-Law – Click Here – which proposed that outdoor events held on private property with more than 500 people should require a permit from the Township. Matthew Helfand, legal representation for the JW Marriott, expressed serious concerns with the proposed by-law. Mr. Helfand explained that the Marriott was proposing to host a Canada Day concert with easy listening Canadian music. It was anticipated that the event would include 2,000 to 3,000 attendees which according to Mr. Helfand the Marriott grounds could “well accommodate”. Mr. Helfand expressed serious concerns with the lack of consultation on the by-law and stated that the “vagueness” of the by-law will do more than regulate a concert and have other consequences. Mr. Helfand concluded by asking that the Marriott be exempt from the by-law for this year’s events.

The owner of the Marriott then spoke stating that they approached the Township in the fall regarding the events and have been very clear with their plans, but following each meeting were met with further requirements. They have found the process frustrating and disappointing as they have tried to be transparent about their plans. Due to a lack of cooperation by the Township, the owner of the Marriott stated that he has moved his September concerts to Niagara Falls.

The third delegation by a local association stated that they were in favour of the by-law as large events outdoors create a number of risks, most of which are concerning safety. Risks include the winding roads in Muskoka, noise, dark sky and garbage.

Later in the meeting James Cox, Economic Development Officer, outlined amendments that had been made to the draft by-law:

  • if the number of people for an outdoor event is lower than the occupancy limit of structures the event will be exempt,
  • additional language was added to the by-law, and
  • transitional provisions for 2024 were formalized.

Councillor Bosomworth asked if proper notice was given to the public under Provincial Regulations for this by-law. Chief Municipal Law Enforcement Officer, Rob Kennedy, explained that no notice was required. Councillor Moyer Kent questioned the rationale of the wording in section 1.16 where the words “and any other plans deemed necessary by the Township” were added to the definition of “Plan”. Mr. Cox explained that he had found similar language while researching other by-laws.

A resolution was read to approve the By-Law Respecting the Permitting, Regulating and Governing of Special Events. The resolution carried.

Municipal Law Enforcement Officer & Property Standards Officer

Council read and approved a by-law to appoint Thomas Jeneway as a Municipal Law Enforcement Officer and Property Standards Officer.

Planning Committee

Lake System Health Water Quality Monitoring Program

Rebecca Willison from the District of Muskoka gave a presentation on Lake System Health in the District  – Click Here. The District of Muskoka has been monitoring water quality for more than 40 years and has found changes over time. The District carries out this water testing to support policies in the Muskoka Official Plan and the Township of Muskoka Lakes Official Plan. In 2023 they monitored 87 sites across 68 lakes across the District, 31 sites and 21 lakes within the Township of Muskoka Lakes. The 2024 program began three weeks ago and involves monitoring 93 sites, 25 of which are in the Township of Muskoka Lakes.

Components of the water quality monitoring program include:

  • Recreational water quality monitoring: where they are seeing a rise in phosphorous
  • Biological monitoring: where they “look at bugs in the mud”
  • Shoreline/land use surveys: where they look at structures on the shoreline, the boundary where the water meets the land and the land itself up to 30 feet from the water’s edge
  • Invasive species: when funding allows, they monitor invasive species along the roadside and attend events and give presentations
  • Love Your Lake Program: this is a shoreline assessment and stewardship program where they complete an overall report for the lake as well as individual reports for properties saying what is good and what could be improved
  • The Natural Edge Program: they provide property owners with what recommendations on what they need to do to re-naturalize their shoreline, including a planting plan if desired
  • Community Outreach: staff attend events and do presentations, as well as hold workshops

Thursday, May 16th, 2024

Process Improvements

Prior to proceeding with the meeting Chair Bosomworth asked for Committee’s indulgence. Chair Bosomworth explained that the Planning Act allows any and all property owners to make an application to the Township and stated that Committee members should not questions the application. Chair Bosomworth requested that Committee members not imply that an applicant will make changes to their submitted documents once an application is approved, as he does not believe Committee should be challenging the integrity of applicants.

Township Heritage Register

Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink, explained that Provincial Bill 23 states that properties listed on the Township’s Heritage list that are not designated by January 1st, 2025 will be removed from the list. The Township currently has 77 properties on their list with 28 of the properties being government-owned and 24 churches, with the remainder being privately owned. Mr. Pink explained that the Architectural Conservancy of Ontario (ACO) has issued a Call To Action urging municipalities to write the Province to request that the deadline be extended to January 1st, 2030.

In reply to a request that the Township establish a Heritage Committee for this term of Council, Mayor Kelley asked Committee’s indulgence and said he will return to Planning with terms of reference for a Heritage Committee.

A resolution to support the call to action by the ACO was read and carried.

Short-Term Rental Accommodation Licensing By-Law

Chief Municipal Law Enforcement Officer, Rob Kennedy, stated that his presentation – Click Here – was a summary of comments made at the February 13th, 2024 public meeting, as well as those made by written submission. Mr. Kennedy explained that 48 individuals had spoken at the public meeting in February and that 171 written submissions had been received. According to Mr. Kennedy the main themes in all submission were:

  • negative towards minimum night stays of seven nights in the “peak season” and three nights in the “off season” with a maximum rental capacity of 50% of the time,
  • that increased by-law enforcement should be considered over a short-term rental licensing by-law,
  • operators who have had not complaints are being tarnished by bad operators,
  • that licensing not be onerous financially or administratively, and
  • that there was general support for some sort of short-term rental by-law.

Staff recommended to Committee that:

  • changes to the minimum number of nights that properties can be rented be reduced to two (2) nights,
  • changes be made to some of the language in the by-law,
  • wording for a “parking management plan” be removed from the by-law and that a “fire safety plan” be incorporated into a site plan,
  • the licensing requirements remove the wording “fire safety plan” and the type of advertising used to rent properties,
  •  the exemption of requiring a license for those renting under 14 days be removed completely,
  • Committee needed to decide on penalties for non-compliance,
  • inspection fees be broken down by Fire Inspection $115.00 per hour, Building Inspection if the structure is more than four years old $250.00, and By-Law Inspection at $200.00 according to the Fees and Charges By-Law, and not a flat rate of $500.00 as previously suggested,
  • the age limit for children be reduced to age two and under, and
  • changes be made to the Renter’s Code of Conduct to include a clause regarding open air fires and that the noise by-law reference be amended to align with the Township’s noise by-law.

Committee held a lengthy and in-depth discussion and made the following decisions:

  • that rentals should be a minimum of six (6) nights during “peak season”,
  • that “peak season” should be extended to include the week before Victoria Day to the Tuesday after Thanksgiving,
  • that property owners should be permitted to rent 75% of the time during “peak season”,
  • that ALL restrictions should be removed during the “off season” (the Tuesday after Thanksgiving to the week before the Victoria Day long weekend) regarding the number of nights renters can stay and how often a premises can be rented,
  • that the age restriction on children be reduced from age 12 to two and under,
  • that the Renter’s Code of Conduct be amended to include fires and that wording regarding noise be amended to align with the Noise By-Law,
  • that the clause regarding renting to “Friends and Family”, referring to property owners who rent for less than 14 days, be deleted pending the outcome of the fee structure,
  • that fines for operating without a license start at $5,000 for a first offense, $10,000 for a second offense and $30,000.00 for a third offense, and
  • that fines for operating with a suspended license start at $10,000.00 for a first offense, $20,000.00 for a second offense and $60,000.00 for a third offense.

A more fulsome report on the discussion about this by-law can be found here – Click Here

A resolution was read that staff be directed to update the Short-Term Rental Accommodation Licensing By-Law and return to a future Planning Committee for consideration. The resolution carried.

ED Note: The Short-Term Rental Accommodation By-Law will return to the Planning Committee before going to Council to be ratified. If you have concerns – for or against the by-law – please contact your Councillors.

Mark Your Calendars

The MRA is hosting a Canadian Anti-Fraud Presentation
on Password & Identity Safety
Wednesday, August 7th, 2024
10 AM at the
Port Carling Community Centre