The following index should help you in locating an article of particular interest
Correction
It has come to our attention that when we were formatting the April Township Watch the number of garbage bags allowed in the rural area was dropped. The sentence should have read:
Weekly garbage collection resumes May 2nd, 2022
with a limit of 2 bags per household in urban areas and
3 bags per household in rural areas.
Garbage bags must be standard household size and
not exceed 55 pounds.
We thank the member who brought this omission to our attention.
General/Finance Committee – Wednesday, May 11th, 2022
Electric Vehicle Charging Station Lease
Committee heard a presentation from Frank Belerique – Vehicle Charging Station – requesting the Township lease to Horizon two parking spots in the Portage Landing Parking Lot for the installation of two electric charging stations. Mr. Belerique explained that Horizon has been in business since 1950 and has been involved with renewable energy for the past 12 years. It was stated that individuals travelling to Bala do not have an opportunity to charge electric vehicles and therefore Horizon is proposing to install two. The proponent wished to start the lease process of two parking spots immediately as it is a lengthy process to obtain the necessary permits and build the charging stations. The proposed lease would be for 10 years with a possible extension of five more. The Township was offered 1% of the gross income from the charging stations, or 10% of the net income.
Committee members voiced concerns with this proposed lease stating and questioning:
- how would Horizon ensure someone did not park in a charging station Friday night and leave their vehicle there the entire weekend,
- that it will be perceived that the charging stations are Township property,
- would the proponent be willing to have two parking spots at the back of the parking lot, and not two right in the entrance?
- for the amount of revenue these charging stations will generate the Township would be better to offer them free of charge,
- charging stations are already available at other locations near Bala,
- owners of electric vehicles do not drive around looking for charging stations they know where they are located, and
- a desire to understand the entire process of leasing lands prior to releasing the parking spots.
CAO Derrick Hammond explained to Committee that the Township had been approached by a member of the private sector to lease the lands and install the charging stations. Mr. Hammond further explained that it is typical for the Township to enter into an agreement to lease lands. Committee members had unanswered questions and requested that staff return with a report. This item was deferred.
Renaming of Muskoka Road 38
CAO Hammond explained that the District has begun an initiative to rename Muskoka Road 38. The first step to this process is to establish a working group with members from the District, Wahta and the Township of Muskoka Lakes. Cheryl Hollows, Manager of Corporate Service/Deputy Clerk was asked to be the Township representative on the Committee. This item was on the agenda for information purposes.
Q1 Financial Update
Director of Financial Services, Mark Donaldson, informed Committee that Township expenses for the first quarter of 2022 are tracking well against the 2022 budget, but the Township is experiencing some cost pressures.
Committee accepted the report – Financial Update – with little discussion and accepted the report as an information item.
Enhanced Hybrid Meetings
Director of Legislative Services, Lauren Tarasuk reminded Committee that in March she provided Committee with a report on how Council and Committee meetings were currently being held. The current process has been a hybrid with the Chair/Mayor in person in the Council Chambers and all other Councillors attending remotely. Although the Council Chambers does currently have webcasting ability, it is not adequate for enhanced hybrid meetings where more than the Chair/Mayor would be present. With the current system Council/Committee members would have to bring their own laptops, turn their microphones on and off and the camera angles would not be adequate, and delegates would be off camera. Ms. Tarasuk explained that holding hybrid meetings has allowed for more public participation and offered the opportunity for delegates to present without having to travel.
Ms. Tarasuk explained that even if all Councillors were to return to the Council Chambers the webcasting available is outdated and better technology to stream meetings will be “wanted by the public”. Although Committee members agreed that they were more productive when they met in person, social distancing regulations are still in place and Councillors and staff are shoulder to shoulder when all attend in person.
Many options were discussed for the request for proposal, including having Councillors located in the Council Chambers but the public located in the Port Carling Community Centre with a camera and microphone. A resolution was read and carried to issue a request for proposal for enhanced audio and video equipment for the Council Chambers and Port Carling Community Centre. The vote carried unanimously.
Council – Wednesday, May 11th, 2022
Regulating the Use of All Terrain Vehicles on Township Roads
Director of Public Works, Ken Becking explained to Council that a one-year trial period had been put in place to allow ATVs on Township roads in April 2016. It appeared that once the one-year trial period had passed, a corresponding by-law was not passed. Mr. Becking stated that a new by-law was before Council for approval.
A resolution to regulate the use of ATVs on Township roads was read and carried.
Hardy Lake Park
In years past the Township had an agreement with the Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry regarding operation and maintenance of Hardy Lake Park at the sole cost to the Township. Recently, discussions between the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks (jurisdiction for the park changed) and the Township regarding the maintenance of the park broke down. Council voted to cease maintaining the park. The MECP reached out to the Township to have further discussions. Mr. Becking reported that the meeting was positive and recommended to Council that the Township continue basic maintenance at Hardy Lake Park for the 2022 season.
Council was concerned about the liability of the Township doing work at Hardy Lake Park and Mr. Becking said he would be reaching out to the Township’s insurers. Concerns were voiced that the public perceives the Township owns Hardy Lake Park and that a lack of maintenance would look poorly on the Township. It was questioned where the garbage would be placed, and if it was not removed it would simply pile up.
A resolution was read that the Township provide basic maintenance including the removal of garbage and upkeep of temporary washroom facilities while the Township continues negotiations with the MECP. The resolution carried in a recorded vote nine to one.
Planning Committee – Thursday, May 12th, 2022
Site Alteration and Tree Preservation By-laws
Chief Municipal Law Enforcement Officer, Rob Kennedy informed Committee that following the last presentation of these by-laws in March 2022 he was instructed to obtain further public input on the by-laws – Site Alteration and Tree Preservation. Since the March meeting Mr. Kennedy spoke to arborists, contractors, and residents of Muskoka Lakes. Mr. Kennedy stated that in the proposed by-laws before Committee, there had been many minor changes that would have “big impacts”, including renaming the Tree Preservation By-law to the Tree Conservation By-law. A high-level graph of some of the proposed changes to the by-laws was included in the agenda package – Summary.
Delegations were heard commenting/questioning the following, but not limited to:
- that the size of stone patios should be regulated according to frontage not simply a set size of 200 square feet,
- how will the Township educate residents on the proposed changes?
- do Township planners have the education to implement the new tree conservation by-law,
- survey results and comments should be available to the public,
- delegates’ comments and concerns are not being addressed, yet more concerns are being raised,
- does the Township intend to “govern” by survey?
- a public meeting needs to be held,
- it appears that only more restrictions are being added to the by-law and public input is not being taken into account,
- these by-laws have been under review since December 2021 and it is time to move forward with them as there are other by-laws that need to be addressed,
- by-law enforcement needs to have the tools to do their job,
- the increase of lands within 200 feet of a waterbody to 300 feet will protect undeveloped lands,
- these by-laws won’t prohibit development, properties will simply be subject to more controls,
- the by-laws are not easy to understand,
- concerns that more restrictive by-laws will not make the by-laws more enforceable,
- the best way to preserve Muskoka is to manage the rules, not add more rules,
- how will the Township process all these new rules?
- there is a cost associated with the studies the Township is requesting, and
- more discussion is needed on the by-laws.
Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink explained the process that has been followed to date. Committee asked staff to prepare a survey on the proposed by-laws which they did and posted it on Engage Muskoka. Staff made changes regarding the spacing in patios and the definition of arborists. The by-laws were posted again on Engage Muskoka. Mr. Pink said that the changes proposed in this draft of the by-law were minor. The proposed by-laws were not “permitting by-laws”, so if a property owner has a site plan application or a building permit, they are permitted to clear trees and alter grades.
Committee members then held a discussion commenting:
- the proposed by-laws are “over reactions”,
- that Mr. Pink provided an excellent explanation to Committee and his words should be written out and provided to the public,
- perhaps trees should be replanted when dead trees are removed,
- patios should be regulated on a sliding scale depending on the size of one’s frontage up to 400 feet,
- people will be affected by these by-laws and the Township must make sure the by-laws are clear and concise,
- in other jurisdictions a by-law officer will meet a developer on site to discuss what can and cannot be done,
- the Township is trying to bring in rules that all “should play by”,
- these by-laws are making things onerous on property owners, and
- a property owner cannot cut down a tree with the way the proposed Tree Conservation by-law reads.
Following the discussion Committee voted to defer the by-laws. Mr. Pink asked Committee for clear direction on what changes are wanted as these by-laws have been presented to Committee several times already. Committee had no changes to be made to the by-laws but felt that a deferral would allow staff a chance to reach out and engage with those who submitted concerns and make sure that all comments/concerns were addressed.
Official Plan Amendment 49
Following the approval of Official Plan Amendment (OPA) 56 regarding the Resort Village of Minett, the OPA was submitted to the District for approval. Prior to approval of OPA 56, the District determined that an amendment to OPA 49 was required to ensure that the upper and lower tier Official Plans were in conformity and consistent.
Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink explained to Committee that the Township wanted fundamental elements such as limiting gross floor area and the number of units in Minett imbedded in the District of Muskoka’s Official Plan. Staff recommended that changes outlined in Appendix “I” – OP Changes – 1 and OPA49 – OP Changes – 2 – be submitted to the District.
A resolution was read and carried unanimously.
New by-law enforcement hours….
Beginning May 21st by-law officers will be working
weekends and holidays 10AM to 6 PM until September 5th, 2022.
Beginning June 6th by-law officers will be working
8AM to 6PM Monday to Friday, as well as
10AM to 6PM weekends and holidays.
Contact the by-law officers on the weekends
and holidays at bylaw@muskokalakes.ca
or by clicking By-Law Enforcement on the Township website
and filling in “report a concern”.
Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.