The following index should help you in locating an article of particular interest
- General/Finance Committee
- Council
- Planning Committee
- Special Planning Committee
- Special Planning Committee
General/Finance Committee – Wednesday, March 16th, 2022
Skeleton Lake Water Access Property Mainland Parking & Docking
Director of Public Works, Ken Becking, informed Committee that staff and stakeholders met to discuss the use of Township lands as mainland parking for water access property owners on Skeleton Lake. Changes were made in the private sector which greatly limited parking available for island property owners – Township Watch – December 2021. The situation facing Skeleton Lake island property owners is not unique in the Township. Mr. Becking felt that attempting to solve this situation in a series of “one offs” would not sufficiently address the situation and should be resolved through a Township policy.
Committee members discussed the situation agreeing that the Transportation Master Plan should be used to develop a policy for parking on Township lands. It was suggested that a municipally owned property known as Lawrence Pit, located 1 km from the Skeleton Lake Road 2 government dock be used as a short-term solution. This parking should be available to the general public, not designated parking spots. Mr. Becking agreed that the use of those lands is the most practical solution.
A resolution was read stating that additional parking access to Skeleton Lake would be studied in the Transportation Master Plan which is scheduled to begin in the third quarter of 2022. Although not included in the resolution, Mr. Becking’s commitment to facilitating a parking area is a matter of public record.
Hybrid Council & Committee Meetings
Director of Legislative Service, Lauren Tarasuk, presented to Committee three options on how to proceed with future Council meetings and asked for input on how Council wished to proceed.
- Option 1: Status Quo – that the Mayor/Chair of the meeting and limited staff be present in the Council Chambers, with additional staff, Council, and members of the public attending via ZOOM.
- Option 2: Investigate Enhanced Hybrid Options – the Council Chambers currently have a basic birds-eye view camera, microphone and screen. This system is not integrated and is not functional for hybrid meetings. Staff could investigate additional technology which would allow for this option.
- Option 3: Removal of all Virtual Options & Require In-Person Attendance – this is not currently an option with physical distancing requirements still in place.
Committee members provided their comments and thoughts on these options stating:
- they reject Option 3,
- as soon as it is safe and permitted, Council should return to meeting in person in one room,
- the enhanced hybrid option should be investigated as it would allow a Councillor who is feeling unwell to attend meetings,
- the Council Chambers are very small,
- Option 2 would continue to give members of the public access to Township meetings,
- it is important not to penalize someone with health issues and force them to attend meetings in person, and
- constituents do not feel part of the process and meetings should start to open up to in-person attendance using the Port Carling Community Centre.
Staff took direction to investigate and return to Committee with information on costs to return to either the Council Chambers or the Port Carling Community Centre. No resolution was read.
COVID-19 Operation Update
CAO, Derrick Hammond, updated Committee on Township operations with COVID-19 restrictions being lifted. Mr. Hammond explained that the Township office and facilities have re-opened to the public. With the lifting of public health restrictions only passive screening, signage, and voluntary masking will be in place. Throughout the pandemic Township staff worked alternatively in the office or remotely which allowed them to continue to provide service to the public. Approximately 40% of Township employees, such as snowplow drivers, parks, maintenance, etc.., continued to work in person during the pandemic. The Township will continue to staff the office with the hybrid method they have been using but, will start to increase staffing commencing in April. Employees, where appropriate, will continue to have access to remote working arrangements. Lastly, as per directions from the Province, testing for unvaccinated employees has ceased.
This report was for information purposes and no resolution was read.
Council – Wednesday, March 16th, 2021
Senior Management Reports
The Council meeting was predominately senior management reports including declaration of surplus lands, a road closing, a license agreement, award of tenders, and by-laws relating to these reports. The meeting also included by-laws and zoning by-laws.
Village Harbour Marina – Site Plan Control
Village Harbour Marina was at Planning Committee last month for a zoning by-law amendment to allow two dwelling units on one property where only one is permitted and to allow a dwelling unit below the high-water mark. This application carried and was recommended to Council for approval. As per policy the application was then heard at Council this month to be ratified.
Village Harbour Marina was also at Council for site plan control on the property. Councillors voiced concerns regarding the use of the property with cabins for rent not being used as a marina and the number of boat slips that will be available to island property owners. Manager of Planning, Bryce Sharpe, explained to committee that if the property is not used as stated it would be an enforcement issue. The number of docking spaces for island property owners was discussed with concerns being raised that the number of spaces was not correct. It was determined that 80% of docks on the property equalling 32 slips should be made available to island property owners on Skeleton Lake.
To alleviate Councillor’s concerns a minor amendment was added to the resolution that stated that the accessory dwelling in the second storey of the boathouse could only be used if a marina was in operation on the property, that staff quarters in the second dwelling could only be used if a marina was in operation on the property and provide a definition of staff quarters, and lastly that a definition of use of the marina including a requirement for 32 boat slips to be made available to land owners on Skeleton Lake.
The resolutions with the above minor amendments added carried.
Planning Committee – Thursday, March 17th, 2022
Floating Accommodations
Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink, informed Committee that the Ministry of Northern Development, Mines, Natural Resources and Forestry were seeking municipal input on the use of “camping” or floating accommodations on Ontario waterways. According to the Ministry there is increased interest in using vessels as overnight accommodations and not for navigation.
Township staff recommended to Committee that the Ministry consider prohibiting this type of floating accommodation, and if not, that vessels moored for extended lengths of time be made subject to Municipal policies and by-laws.
Following a brief discussion where Committee members voiced concerns about “camping on water” and were in agreement to prohibit them, a resolution was read to forward comments to the Ministry of Northern Development, Mines, Natural Resources and Forestry and was carried unanimously.
Discretionary Sewage Maintenance Inspection Policy
Chief Building Official, Nick Snyder, informed Committee that the Township survey which was available from January 10th, 2022 to February 17th, 2022 had elicited 216 replies – Sewage Survey – and that the majority of replies where in support of the new policy – Sewage Inspection Policy
Committee members posed questions and comments:
- regarding how summer students are trained,
- that they keep hearing comments about problems, but the lakes continue to become healthier,
- that education is paramount,
- that not all septic systems are bad, and
- are more summer septic inspectors needed,
- the Township wants to protect water and septic systems,
- could the Township require a septic inspection upon sale of a property,
- if a septic inspection is done with the sale of a property, encourage the new owners to submit the results to the Township for the database,
- request that a Phase 1 septic inspection be done within six to eight months of a property being sold,
- waiting 12 months to implement the policy is inappropriate,
- that Committee likes the policy but are not sure of the details, and
- that the Township continue with the current septic inspection program while establishing the required database and then have staff return with a policy.
Following this discussion it was determined that the Township would build the required database on septic systems around the Township, prior to discussing how to implement the new policy. Committee requested that staff return in six months with an update on the progress of establishing the necessary database.
A resolution was read to continue with the current septic inspection program and that further review and discussion of the policy will occur once the database of all on-site private sewage systems in the Township has been compiled. The resolution carried.
ED Note: The Muskoka Ratepayer’s comments submitted on the discretionary sewage maintenance inspection policy can be read here – Ratepayers’ Comments
Site Alteration and Tree Preservation By-Law
Delegations were heard on the draft site alteration and tree preservation by-law –Site Alteration – making comments that included, but were not limited to the following:
- that the Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability should be given the ability to deny permits if the requested work will hurt the natural environment,
- information on permits should be specific regarding where blasting will be done, what site alteration will occur, which trees will be removed, where sediment will be placed etc…
- that the site control by-law should also be updated in conjunction with these by-laws,
- wording should be included to prohibit removal of trees prior to permits being issued,
- “over-limbing” of trees should be controlled,
- releasing a report on Friday and discussing it the following Thursday does not allow sufficient time to review it,
- since the meeting in December 2021, only a survey has been done on these by-laws,
- site alteration should only be regulated in the first 200 feet,
- including entire islands should be reconsidered,
- local arborists should have been consulted,
- there will be significant financial impacts on arborists with this by-law,
- the reckless actions of a few should not be “taken out” on all arborists, and
- wording should be altered to allow by-law enforcement officers to do their jobs.
Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink explained that staff had not spoken to any “groups” such as arborists. The increase of lands effected from 200 feet to 300 feet and the inclusion of entire islands were not a staff suggestion but direction of Council. Mr. Pink clarified that the by-law does not require tree removal by certified arborists, but if a property owner wishes to remove trees as they are diseased, a qualified individual must substantiate that the trees are diseased. This by-law will not impact individuals who only cut trees that are permitted to be removed but is required to regulate those who violate the tree cutting by-law.
Committee members held an in-depth discussion on the by-law stating that:
- comments should be heard from arborists, contractors, and professional planners in the community,
- this by-law was drafted due to a “few bad apples” and it will do more harm to others,
- the water in Lake Muskoka is currently healthier than ever,
- the public have voiced concerns regarding the by-law,
- Committee has not had enough time to review the by-law, and
- further time is needed to fully understand the by-law.
With so many questions being raised, it was decided that a “pause” be put on passing the by-law. Mr. Pink was asked to put his comments to Committee in writing and post them on the Engage Muskoka site to help clarify questions and confusion regarding who this by-law is attempting to regulate. Mr. Pink and Chief Municipal By-Law Enforcement Officer, Rob Kennedy were asked to return to Committee with responses to questions that were asked and editing on definitions in the document. It was suggested that the public be given greater time to review the document when it is returned to Committee for further discussion. Lastly, it was stated that if members of the public have concerns and wish to meet to voice them, that staff facilitate those requests. Chair Bridgeman stated that the public could contact her as Chair of Planning Committee, Mr. Pink or Mr. Kennedy.
No resolution was read on the site alteration and tree preservation by-law.
ED Note: The Muskoka Ratepayers comments submitted on the Site Alteration and Tree Preservation By-law can be read here – Ratepayers’ Comments
Special Planning Committee – Friday, March 18th, 2022
Legal Non-Complying Lot Provisions & Accessory Building Provisions
At a Special Planning Committee on Friday, March 18th, 2022, Manager of Planning, Bryce Sharpe explained that this was a municipally initiated amendment to the Township Comprehensive Zoning By-Law for legal non-complying lot provisions across the Township and accessory building provisions in the waterfront designation. Staff were returning to Committee with a staff report – Legal Non-Complying – with revisions to the by-law following the public meeting in September 2021.
Delegations commented and raised concerns regarding:
- “arresting of development is not reasonable”,
- wording on the previous legal non-complying by-law should be amended,
- second storey addition restrictions are targeting small lots,
- property owners should be allowed to expand shoreline structures as a right permitting that they abide by current by-laws,
- the height change to accessory structure to allow 25 feet is an improvement,
- garages should be permitted to have two-piece washrooms and hoses,
- modern boats are bigger and longer,
- prohibiting decks and balconies on accessory structures would be a good thing, and
- if plumbing is permitted in accessory structures septic capacity should be verified.
Committee members then voiced concerns with legal non-complying lot provisions stating that:
- the only reason Committee is talking about legal non-complying lot provisions is that the Township’s language in the by-law was challenged which has removed property rights,
- the wording in the by-law should be rewritten to reflect the interpretation that the Township has always used, and
- do not see a need to freeze development on undersized lots.
Committee further reviewed the staff report discussing:
- that the wording for sideyard setbacks was acceptable,
- that redevelopment of buildings that exceed lot coverage should be permitted in the second storey if upper balconies and decks were prohibited, and
- that the wording for shoreline structures that exceed cumulative width needs to be redrafted prior to a public meeting.
Committee had varied opinions on accessory structures in the waterfront designation and how they should be limited, including but not limited to:
- where a cottage, sleeping cabin and boathouse are permitted, one more accessory structure should be permitted,
- the Township is becoming very restrictive when it is not needed,
- that only two-piece bathrooms be permitted in accessory structures,
- the Township does not need to make things more difficult for property owners, it just needs to enforce current by-laws,
- “living” should take place in the main dwelling and accessory structures can be used for a gym, an office, etc…, and
- this by-law was reactive to “bad players”.
Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink explained that this amendment was not about lot coverage and built form but controlling the use of accessory structures. Mr. Pink further stated that this was a municipally initiated amendment and if Committee was not happy with it, the process could be stopped as they were not obligated to makes changes to accessory buildings.
It was decided that the wording of this portion of the by-law with the addition of prohibition on bathrooms should be sent for public input. Chair Bridgeman reminded all present that this wording is to obtain public input, it does not mean it will remain this way.
A resolution was read and carried that a revised draft by-law be prepared as directed at the meeting and a public meeting be scheduled as required by the Planning Act.
ED Note: A date for the public meeting will be released later.
Special Planning Committee – Tuesday, March 22, 2022
Official Planning Public Input Review
The Planning Committee met to review and discuss public input received on draft one of the Official Plan (OP) – OP Review Survey . Prior to beginning discussions Committee heard from delegates who made comments regarding, but not limited to:
- rezoning resorts,
- adding density restriction on commercial properties,
- that the language in the OP needs to be more “committal”
- aggregate use should require a setback of 2 km from a waterbody,
- a “hard cap” with Recreational Carrying Capacity should be on small lakes,
- limits should be on rural lot creations,
- deeded mainland parking for water access lots is a sledgehammer to deal with on street parking problems,
- property owners should be able to choose how they use the lower level of their boathouses,
- the required causation studies for lot development is an “overstep”,
- how will maximum amenity areas be enforced?,
- many questions have been asked without receiving replies, and
- numbers should be removed from the OP and dealt with in Township by-laws.
Committee then heard Nick McDonald, consultant from Meridan Planning, review his recommendations – Meridian Plan – and held discussions on each issue. In-depth and thoughtful discussions were held raising the following points:
- Committee was in agreement with removing deeded mainland parking for water access properties,
- a clear definition of a marina and a landing would be helpful,
- that the wording for the use of the first storey of a boathouse as “accessory recreational use” is so flexible you “can drive a truck through it”
- the first storey of a boathouse could be used to get out of the sun but cannot have habitable space such as kitchens,
- people will build larger boathouses if they are permitted 50% as recreational space,
- 50% of the first floor of a boathouse for recreational space is too high and the amount should be limited to a certain square footage,
- increasing the size of waterfront lots is making Muskoka unaffordable at times,
- how long will the wait be for causation studies to be conducted before lot development can occur on certain small lakes,
- Site Plan Approval being required on all new dwellings, additions to dwellings and buildings which will increase the gross floor area by 50 square metres or greater, dwellings being relocated on a property, new sleep cabins, new boathouses, and expansion of boathouses greater than 50 square metres, and new accessory buildings greater than 50 square metres will have an impact on Township staffing requirements,
- that the maximum amenities coverage area be dealt with through the site alteration by-law,
- wording for site alteration should be included in the OP but not specific numbers,
- recreational carrying capacity (RCC) is a good tool in regulating development but it should not be the only tool,
- RCC does not take into consideration people using lakes from public boat launches,
- that the RCC is creating unfairness around lakes and if restrictive rules are put in place for new lots, the same restrictions should be put in place for current lots,
- commercial resorts are important to the Township, but density and usage should be controlled,
- down-zoning of small resorts should be a last resort after all other avenues have been investigated as once down-zoned they will no longer be considered employment lands, and
- that Walkers Point be referred to as a Local Community Area as they are not recognized as a settlement area by the District Official Plan and therefore cannot be by the Township’s OP.
Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, David Pink explained to Committee he believed that between staff and the consultants a second draft of the OP could be written in one or two months. It would then return to Committee for a public meeting to be called….perhaps in June or July. Following that, depending on feedback from the public, it could be considered for adoption by the Township. Mr. Pink gave no time guarantees on when the adoption of the OP may occur but stated that staff will try to conclude the OP during this term of Council.
A resolution was read to direct staff to provide a second draft of the Official Plan for Committee’s consideration. The resolution passed unanimously.
ED Note: The Muskoka Ratepayers would like to thank staff, Committee and the advisory group who have all worked so diligently on the Official Plan.
The Muskoka Ratepayers will be switching
to our new website in the coming weeks.
Although we do not anticipate any disruption in our website,
we apologize if some occurs.
Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.