General/Finance Committee

Cannabis Retail in the Township of Muskoka Lakes

Owen Allerton, co-owner of Highland Cannabis in Kitchener with his wife, was before Committee to ask for support in opening a cannabis retail store in the Township of Muskoka Lakes. Mr. Allerton explained that he was a graduate of Laurier University and operated one of the top ten stores in the Province. Mr. Allerton stated that “the gold rush” regarding cannabis stores is over. Of the original 2000 license application submitted in the Province for cannabis stores, 1300 remain and he believes that number will decrease even further to approximately 1000. The Allerton’s own property in the Township of Muskoka Lakes and asked Council to reconsider a cannabis retail store in the Township. Mr. Allerton’s presentation can be found here – Click Here.

Councillor Zavitz explained that he and another Councillor had brought this item forward and said he would be disappointed if staff were not challenged to return with a report. Committee held a short discussion and a resolution was read to direct staff to review Mr. Allerton’s proposal and to return with a staff report. The resolution carried.

Wednesday, December 13th, 2023

Muskoka Lakes Snow Trails Association

Steve Elliott, President of the Muskoka Lakes Snow Trails Association, along with Vice President Steve Walter delegated to Committee asking for support of their association. They explained that they have a Board of ten individuals and volunteers. To be able to use snowmobile trails you must buy a permit for $230.00. According to Mr. Elliott these monies go to the Province of Ontario and are returned to the association to pay for the machinery that grooms the trails and for gas. Mr. Walters explained that they are looking for support to obtain a piece of property to call their own. The association currently has a five-year lease on lands that belong to the District and are raising funds for a building to store their groomer and hold board meetings but are hesitant to do so on lands they do not own when they do not know what the future of their lease is. The full presentation can be seen here – Click Here.

A resolution was read to direct staff to facilitate discussions with the Muskoka Lakes Snow Trails Association and return to Committee with a staff report. The resolution carried.

Muskoka Lakes Chamber of Commerce

Mr. Randy Heyd, President of the Muskoka Lakes Chamber of Commerce (MLCC), presented to Committee the 2023 Year End MLCC Report. Mr. Heyd explained that the MLCC represents all four corners of the Township and has the highest media presence of all Muskoka Chambers with 4100 Facebook followers, 3263 Instagram followers and 2941 Twitter followers. In 2023 the MLCC printed 15,000 guidebooks, provided quality events, increased their membership by 20% and supported local businesses by directing visitors to local businesses. Mr. Heyd’s presentation can be seen here – Click Here.

Committee did not have any questions for Mr. Heyd. This item was for information and no resolution was read.

ED Note: The MRA congratulates the MLCC for being able to increase their membership by 80 in 2023.

Fire Station Location Study – Phase 1 Update

Fire Chief Murrell explained to Committee that following recommendations made in the Fire Master Plan, Emergency Management Group Inc (EMG) was hired to consult on the fire station location study. Phase I has been completed and consisted of an analysis of call volumes and response times, site visits to all Township Fire Stations and three in person meetings with firefighters. Chief Murrell informed Committee that there is a significant overlap for response in the southwestern part of the Township, that seven of ten fire stations lack space to house modern fire equipment and that there is a lack of storage in fire halls.

Lyle Quan from EMG explained that he had led the Fire Master Plan and that recommendations put forward had been:
• A consideration of closing two fire stations,
• A new five station model, and
• The creation of three key stations with four substations to support them.

Larry Brassard, Project Lead Consultant, explained that Phase I was to gather data and Phase II will be to return with what they feel are “best solutions”. Mr. Brassard explained that the Township uses a “variable response model” when responding to structure fires which means that a minimum of three stations respond to a structure fire. While complying data, Mr. Brassard said they looked at the standard and best practices in Ontario, the Ontario Building Code, the Ontario Fire Code, Occupational Health & Safety, Accessibility for Ontarians with Disability Act, Community Risk Assessment and the National Fire Protection Association Standards. It was determined that the fire stations in the Township of Muskoka Lakes are generally not falling down, but one is close to 80 years old. Chief Murrell’s report can be read here – Click Here, and EMG’s report can be read here – Click Here.

Although this item was on the agenda for information, Mr. Brassard and Chief Murrell answered Committee’s questions. Councillor Nishikawa raised concerns about how the Bala fire station will respond to Nile Mile Lake with the train tracks and newly reduced speed limit between Bala and Torrance, and questioned if the fire boat will remain in Torrance. Chief Murrell explained that every option was “still on the table”, his department was continually recruiting people and that he did not see the fire boat in Torrance being relocated. Councillor Edwards questions why fire fighters do not go directly to fire instead of going to the station and deploying from there. Chief Murrell explained that having private vehicles at calls can be a safety issue. Furthermore, if fire fighters respond directly to a scene, they need to keep their gear in their personal vehicles. This is not ideal as there is a chemical in the waterproofing of fire fighting gear that is a “forever chemical” and volunteers’ family/friends could be exposed to the chemical if the gear was left in personal vehicles.

CAO Hammond stated that it is important to realize that all options are being reviewed, public input will be sought and then there will be a service level review study conducted to discuss recommendations where there will be even further public input/community involvement. As this item was for information purposes no resolution was read.

Corporate Asset Management Plan

Director of Public Works, Ken Becking reminded Committee that a corporate asset management plan is a mandatory requirement by the Province of Ontario and must be completed by July 1st, 2024. Mr. Becking informed Committee that the Township of Muskoka Lakes has $620.00 million of assets under their control which are “generally speaking in good condition”, but $70.1 million of those assets are in “poor to very poor” condition and $149.4 million are beyond their “useful lives”. Mr. Becking referred to graphs in his oral presentation that demonstrated that the Township is allowing assets to deteriorate and then trying to restore them. This is not an ideal situation as one cannot continually put “band aids” on $70 million worth of assets. Mr. Becking explained to Committee that tough and fundamental decisions will have to be made and that the Township needs to be a knowledgeable owner of its assets. Furthermore, Mr. Becking felt it was extremely important to keep the Township’s Assets Management Plan “up to date” and to not let it sit on a shelf. It will be up to Council to set the necessary service level, then the Director of Financial Services will provide Council with the cost of such services and Council will have to decide to proceed or say no and revise the level of service. These decisions need to be completed by the end of the first quarter of 2025. The Township will then be in a position to complete the final version of the Corporate Asset Management Plan that has to be adopted by July 1st, 2025.

Mr. Becking further explained that two-thirds of the assets that need repairs are core assets such as roads and bridges, items that the Township “cannot get rid of”. When asked if there were items that could be used to mitigate these huge expenses, Mr. Becking stated that the Township could provide “barest of minimum” service levels but he did not believe that the public would like those standards. Mr. Becking advised Committee that they should adopt a measured and thoughtful approach and “up their game but in a gradual way”. Another problem Mr. Becking pointed out is that in his opinion Muskoka is challenged due to the “dirth of qualified contractors” which is demonstrated when the Township put out a Request for Proposal and only receive one applicant. CAO Hammond emphasized that the 2025 deadline is “real” and may have potential impacts from funding from the Province if they are not completed.

Mr. Becking acknowledged that his report – Click Here, and the Executive Summary – Click Here – were lengthy and asked Committee to review the plan further and submit any further questions or comments to him over the holiday season. Mr. Becking will then return in January 2024 with an updated version for Committee to consider adopting. A resolution was read to accept the plan and that Councillors submit questions/comments to Mr. Becking. The resolution carried.

Council

2024 Draft Operating and Capital Budget and Forecast

Director of Financial Services, Mark Donaldson, reviewed for Council that he had been asked to increase contributions to reserves by an extra $1,000,000.00 in 2024, which brought the tax levy to 15.7% over the approved 2023 tax levy. This equates to an increase of $18.58 per $100,000.00 of property assessment for the Township’s portion of your tax bill. Following a discussion on a request from funding by Muskoka Lakes Pickleball, Council voted to approve the 2024 budget.

Wednesday, December 13th, 2023

By-Laws and Zoning By-Laws

Several by-laws including a Burning By-law, Property Standards By-law and an amendment to the Administrative Monetary Penalty System By-law were read and carried with no discussion.

Planning Committee

Community Planning Permit System

This item was originally presented by the Manager of Planning, Bryce Sharpe at the November 2023 Planning Committee and reported in the November 2023 Township Watch – Township Watch – November 2023 – Mr. Sharpe returned to the Planning Committee this month with an enhanced presentation – Click Here – on the proposed Community Planning Permit System (CPPS) which if implemented would replace the Township’s Comprehensive Zoning By-Law (CZBL). Mr. Sharpe explained what a CPPS is, how there are different “classes” for approvals, that a CPPS would streamline the application process, staff will be delegated more authority to make decisions, that appeal rights will be removed from neighbours and reviewed Pro’s and Con’s for a CPPS.

Prior to beginning the question period Chair Bosomworth stated that the CPPS is a “very significant change” for the Township and that it was important that Committee fully understand what the CPPS means to the Township from all stakeholders’ points of view. Committee spent several hours posing questions to staff to further understand the CPPS and were informed that:

• a change in zoning would continue to be heard by Committee
• a request for a significant increase in height would be heard by Committee
• if authority is not delegated to staff in the CPPS efficiencies will be lost
• if an application is delegated to staff but raised to Committee, a public circulation will be done, notices will be published, staff will visit the property and write a report, but there would be no public meeting where members of the public can stand to speak, individuals will be required to register as a delegation
• as laid out in the Planning Act staff do not currently have authority to impose conditions on zoning by-laws
• the use of a CPPS is to make processing applications more efficient and quicker
• staff hope that items delegated to staff will “incentivize” applicants to ask for less as the process will be quicker
• additional staff will not be required if a CPPS is put in place
• decisions must be made with a CPPS in 45 days, and
• staff felt obligated to bring this process to Committee, but if Councillors wish to continue with the CZBL staff are happy to oblige.

Committee then entered into a discussion period; Mayor Kelley expressed that he believes that leaders do not delegate important decisions as decision authority goes with those who are responsible. Mayor Kelley further stated that he was not sure why a change in process was being made as he feels that the current process works well, and that it is his belief that the more minds that review an item the better but the proposed CPPS feels like “pre-programming”. Councillor Roberts stated that he was excited about the CPPS but nervous as well, and questioned if a working group should be established on the CPPS and local planners should be asked to participate. Councillor Burry was “dead set against” the CPPS. Councillor Moyer Kent agreed with Councillor Burry but stated that she saw some advantages to the CPPS but not at the current time. Councillor Edwards concurred with Mayor Kelley that the system that was currently in use was “not broken”. Councillor Mazan asked for further time to review the CPPS prior to having to vote on it. Councillor Zavitz supported a deferral for 30 days.

A resolution was read and carried to return this item to the January 2024 Planning Committee.

ED Note: Members of the MRA Board met with Planning staff to further understand the CPPS and are monitoring the process.

Thursday, December 14th, 2023

District Council

District Budget

Following a presentation by Commissioner of Finance and Corporate Services, Suzanne Olimer, District Council voted to approve the District’s 2024 Tax Supported Operating Budget and Capital Budget and Forecast. The District portion of your property taxes will increase 3.94%, plus 0.4% for the redevelopment of local hospitals. This equates to an increase of $40.38 per every $300,000.00 of assessed property value.

Monday, December  18th, 2023

The Board of the Muskoka Ratepayers
wish all of you and your families
a Happy and Healthy 2024.