General/Finance Committee

Fish Hatchery Road to be Designated as Community Safety Zone

Manager of Public Works, Tim Sopkowe, explained to Committee that the District of Muskoka has recently deemed all District roads adjacent to schools Community Safety Zones. The District then asked all lower tier municipalities to do the same with their road network. As Watt Public School is adjacent to Fish Hatchery Road Mr. Sopkowe was asking Committee to support its designation.

It was questioned if the Township would be asking the Province to do the same on Highway 141 in front of Watt Public School. Mr. Sopkowe explained that in order to so the Province would require a resolution from the Township and the District and would require the OPP’s support. Mr. Sopkowe further explained that speed and Community Safety Zones are two different items and the MTO is responsible for setting the speed limit.

Ultimately a resolution was read to support the Community Safety Zone on Fish Hatchery Road and request that the District consult with the Province regarding having Highway 141 designated as well. The resolution carried.

Wednesday, August 13th, 2025

Q2 Financial Update Presented to Committee

Manager of Financial Services, Marilyn Jeffrey, presented the Q2 financial report to Committee. The report – Click Here – reviewed operating expenses and revenue from January 1st, 2025 to June 30th, 2025. As of June 30th, 2025 the Township had 47.6% of its Operating Budget remaining for the year. Although the Q2 financial update includes cost of $936,885.00 from the March 2025 ice storm, the Township has applied for $584,800 from the Municipal Ice Storm Assistance program. As the Short-Term Rental Accommodation By-Law portal did not open until the end of July 2025 the Q2 report does not show any revenue from the by-law.

This item was for Committee’s information and no resolution was read.

$607K of Capital Projects Cancelled or Deferred to Cover Operating Deficit

As reported in the July Township Watch  the Township experienced unexpected costs from winter storms and a lack of revenue due to the delay of the launch of the Short-Term Rental Accommodation By-Law. Director of Financial Services, Mark Donaldson, was before Committee with Capital Projects that could be scaled back, deferred or cancelled. Mr. Donaldson explained that following review of the Capital Budget, savings of $607,200.00 were found and were listed in Appendix 1 – Click Here – of the staff report.

A concern was raised that the taxpayers would bear the brunt of this budget shortfall, to which Mr. Donaldson stated that there will not be 100% recovery of these costs and that the unfortunate reality is that infrastructure and service costs “are what they are.”

A resolution being read stating that $607,200.00 of capital projects be cancelled or deferred and that the same amount be tra.nsferred from reserve funds to the tax stabilization reserves. Last that the Treasurer report back to Committee with final budget variances for the Short-Term Rental Accommodation By-Law and winter control costs including the costs of the March 2025 ice storm. Committee voted on the resolution and it carried.

Election Sign By-Law Updated to Align with Other Municipalities

Director of Legislative Services, Crystal Paroschy, informed Committee that administrative changes had been made to Election Sign By-Law to provide consistency across Muskoka. Many of the changes in the by-law are simply wording or restructuring of sections, but two significant changes are in the definitions and prohibiting election signs on public property including road allowances. Clerks across the District of Muskoka outlined their reasons for these changes in the staff report which can be read here – Click Here. A red line version of the by-law can be seen here – Click Here.

It was raised that during the last election candidates were placing signs in front of businesses and the business owners were not necessarily aligned with those individuals. Ms. Paroschy explained that if signs were placed on road allowances in front of businesses nothing could be done about it, but signs cannot be placed on private property without permission. A concern was raised that if someone was running for election and did not know property owners across their Ward then they would not be able to erect election signs. One member of Committee commented that Ontario has a long history of having election signs and by not allowing election signs on the public roadway it is removing a main avenue of a candidate having their name in the public realm. In follow up to questions Ms. Paroschy explained that there was no problem with the Township’s election sign by-law, this was simply being brought forward to be consistent with other municipalities.

The original resolution put forward by staff was amended to state the Committee deny the Draft Election Sign By-Law, to strike paragraphs two and three, that staff will receive comments for 30 days from Committee members regarding changes to the by-law and that staff conduct a review and make updates to the by-law for clarification. The amended by-law was read and carried.

Seven-Fire-Station Model Accepted, More Public Consultation to Come

Chief Murrell was before Committee to present the Fire Station Location Study which was received in July 2024 and was referred for consideration with the Level of Service Study that was adopted in July 2025. Chief Murrell requested the Committee receive and adopt the seven station model for the Township of Muskoka Lakes. Chief Murrell explained that the review of the number of fire stations in the Township is not a “new matter” and has been ongoing since 2014. Some of the fire stations in the Township are old, lack space to fit equipment and vehicles and require upgrades for safety reasons.

The staff report – Click Here – included in the agenda package outlined that the seven fire station model would see the closure of the Glen Orchard, Raymond and Torrance fire stations over the next nine years. The fire stations in Windermere and Walker’s Point would be modernized and the stations in Foot’s Bay, Milford Bay, Minett and Bala would be rebuilt in the next 20 years. The Fire Station Location Study can be read here – Click Here.

Committee held an extensive discussion asking questions and making comments including but not limited to:

  • Did the Fire Chief received any feedback on the fire location study prior to five days before? Chief Murrell replied he had not.
  • There are concerns from the public that they will lose their fire halls and their insurance will be affected. Chief Murrell stated he would not suggest this would be a slower arrival model, when a fire call is made three stations respond and the seven station model is the right thing for the community. Regarding insurance costs Chief Murrell said that some insurance companies say you have to be with 8 KMs of a fire station while others say 13 KMs.
  • Will the seven station model continue to meet the National Fire Protection Association standards? Chief Murrell stated that it would, as with the 10 station model there is a lot of overlap.
  • That there is a perception that the Township is reducing the number of fire stations to save money. Chief Murrell explained that the seven station model was a “good option” and staff can run it effectively and confidently, but if the will of Committee was a ten station model they would continue with it.
  • Concerns have only been raised from one area where there is a potential fire station closure.
  • That a decision should be made and then defer ratification at Council for a couple of months.
  • That the matter should be deferred at the meeting and then voted on in 60 days to allow residents to “have their say” as many were not aware of these potential closures.
  • Residents are “scratching their heads” regarding these closures.
  • The experts are telling the Township that a seven station model will be effective and Committee should trust the system.

When asked about further public engagement, CAO Pink explained that staff will take direction from Committee, but stated that public input was previously received on the Fire Station Location Study. It was stated that there are two types of public engagement, one to obtain input and a second to educate the public on the relevant information. It was then decided that the Township should “throw all communications” they can to help with the fears associated with these potential changes.

A resolution was read to accept the seven station model but prior to it being ratified by Council in October that notification of these recommendations be provided to the community, that public consultation be made available and that staff be directed to analyze and report back on any feedback received. The resolution carried in a recorded vote of 9 to 1 with Councillor Edwards voting against it.

ED Note: If you have concerns to voice or wish more information or clarification on the station closures please contact the Council and Fire Chief Murrell. Email addresses are attached – Click Here

Use of Public Docks By-Law Amended

Manager of Parks, Recreation and Facilities, Corey Moore, presented to Committee the results of public input on two large capital project – replacing the Beaumaris and Windermere wooden docks.  Staff also “dove into the operations of the wharves” in connection with this discussion. The process began with public engagement on the layout of the docks and discussions with wharf managers. Although there are many public docks within the Township only three – Foot’s Bay, Windermere and Beaumaris – offer parking by permit. Permits are sold at Windermere and Beaumaris for boats that will be parked for over four hours, as well as “seasonal parking permits.” Upon review of the data staff were suggesting that more boat parking would be available at Windermere if the Township eliminates seasonal parking permits.

Mr. Moore informed Committee that staff believed three options were available to them:

  1. status quo,
  2. add additional parameters including how many permits can be issued as they are now organized by the wharf masters, or
  3. the removal of season parking permits and simply allow boat parking for transient use.

Staff were recommending Option 3 with minor options:

  • Option 1: reduce the number of wharves with seasonal slips.
  • Option 2: exempts some wharves.
  • Option 3: dispose of wharves.

Mr. Moore explained that while public feedback is important it is only one part of the process. Mr. Moore questioned if the Township wished to be in the business of providing boat slips to some residents. The original use of a seasonal pass was repeated use of the dock and not having to buy a pass each time, not for overnight or continuous use.

Committee held a lengthy discussion on the topic of amending the by-law, voicing comments and concerns including but not limited to:

  • The results from the Beaumaris survey were very clear that they wished to remain status quo and this recommendation was from all who responded.
  • That the Township cannot take boat parking away from residents without a solution for where they will park.
  • It is not “fair” that the Township is subsidizing some land owners and not others by providing mainland parking.
  • These assets belong to the public and should be turned over often.
  • At the very least those that use the docks as seasonal parking should be given warning this use may stop.
  • Short-term parking should be raised from four hours to five hours.
  • A transition period should be offered of three to five years as property owners have been using this dock for years.
  • That no overnight parking should be added to the by-law.

CAO Pink stated that staff are aware of the implications of this by-law amendment for those who use the dock, but it is going to cost hundreds of thousands of dollars to replace the Beaumaris dock and it should not be done for the benefit of a few but paid for by all. Seasonal permits are being issued by wharf managers based on history, yet all taxpayers are paying for the docks. Director of Legislative Services reminded Committee that staff were looking for direction with the by-law and that no decisions were being made at that time.

A resolution was read which included wording to proceed with the Option 3 but return with a “roll out plan” for a new approach, that the Township’s business not include seasonal slips, that a phased approach to any changes in Beaumaris and Windermere be used, that short-term docking be increased up to a maximum of five hours, that fees be raised to market rate and that overnight parking be restricted. The resolution passed in a recorded vote 8 to 1 with Councillor Zavitz voting against it.

Windermere Wharf Layout Approved, Beaumaris Postponed

Manager of Parks, Recreation and Facilities, Corey Moore, brought Committee up-to-date on the status of the Windermere and Beaumaris dock rebuilds – Click Here.  Committee first heard that survey results showed that those in Windermere were interested in seeing more parking, an improved layout, aesthetics and better safety. The option being put forward was a floating dock that looks very similar to the current docking with more parking spaces available including “a few” for longer boats. Many of those who replied to the survey voiced concerns about keeping the beach area safe, with that in mind the canoes and kayaks have been moved to the other side of the beach. In reply to the question of how many seasonal permit holders there are for the Windermere docks, Mr. Moore replied 16. A concern was raised that it was not possible to define “the form” of these docks without knowing who would be the users of them, as if the Township was going to eliminate season passes and overnight parking more slips may not be required.

Mr. Moore then explained that survey results indicated that those who use the wooden dock in Beaumaris would like it replaced in the same layout. The one change staff were recommending was to replace the cribs with a steel dock. It was questioned why a floating dock would not be used, to which Mr. Moore replied that steel pillars will last longer. Further concerns were raised with the use of a steel dock, Mr. Moore suggested that staff could receive prices and quotes on various types of docking. The concern of replacing the dock without knowing who the users would be was raised again.

A resolution was read to approve the dock layout in Windermere including that the public be notified and any comments be received prior to Council consideration. A second resolution was read to postpone the Beaumaris dock replacement until Council finalizes the use of public docks by-law with staff reporting back on different types of materials that could be used.

Council

Senior Management Team Reports & By-Laws

The agenda for the Council meeting included one senior staff report, zoning by-laws and general & planning by-laws.

Wednesday, August 13th, 2025

Planning Committee

Request that the Zoos and Wildlife Sanctuaries By-Law Limit Care to Native Animals

A private citizen, Paula White, delegated to Committee on behalf of herself and other concerned residents regarding the Township’s Noise By-Law and Zoos and Sanctuaries By-Law. Ms. White stated that she understood that the Noise By-Law is to be reviewed this coming fall and suggested that the definition of noise, barking, whining or other similar persistent sound made by a dog or domestic pet be amended to strengthen the by-law. Ms. White further asked that the Zoos & Sanctuaries By-Law be limited to providing care solely for species native to the Province of Ontario. This request was being made due to a lack of Provincial legislation regarding exotic animals in Ontario which would make licensing, regulating and governing any related by-laws, and the associated costs the responsibility of the Township of Muskoka Lakes. The delegation included four suggested amendments to the current by-law. Ms. White’s full delegation can be read here – Click Here.

Committee held a discussion on the delegation and it was raised that the Noise By-Law is slated for review. In reply to a question, Director of Development Services and Environmental Sustainability, Jennifer Huff, explained to Committee that she had not received the full presentation prior to the meeting and would require time to review it. Ms. Huff stated that Ms. White’s proposals could be taken into consideration when the Zoos & Sanctuaries By-Law was reviewed. Ms. Huff further clarified that the Zoos & Sanctuaries By-Law allows for enforcement on a complaint basis, inspections can be completed, licenses can be verified, and suspended or revoked if required.

After receiving comments from Committee Ms. Huff stated that she is hearing a desire to review the Zoos & Sanctuaries By-Law but it was currently not on the list of by-laws to be reviewed. It was requested that staff return with a list of by-laws scheduled for review.

This item was for information and no resolution was read.

Thursday, August 14th, 2025

According to a Township press release:
the Fire Danger Rating has been downgraded
from HIGH to Moderate, effective
Wednesday, August 27th, 2025.

Click here for more information